WPW Breaks Down Synthetic vs Leather Gloves (Superskin, Pro Mesh)

jarrod-dyson-rawlings-pro-mesh-glove

Jarrod Dyson’s Rawlings Pro Mesh

BY KYLE O’CONNOR

Companies such as Rawlings, Nike, and Wilson are starting to make more and more synthetic gloves.  They say that synthetic materials in choice areas make the glove lighter, more durable, and add other benefits without sacrificing utility.  We can take their word for it, but you know that’s not how it works around here.  So, pros: synthetics vs Leather?

Rawlings

Rawlings offers a few synthetic options: mesh and suede. Although suede is seen every once in a while on a pitcher’s glove, mesh is the most popular synthetic material Rawlings offers. Pros like Yadier Molina, Adam Jones, and Alcides Escobar use, or have used the Rawlings mesh.

Adam Jones

Adam Jones’ Rawlings PRO303-6SLM

As for the quality of the mesh, there are a few benefits to mesh:

  • Lighter weight: Rawlings says 10-15%, and that seems about right.
  • Breathability: Mesh is more porous than leather, letting more air into the hand opening for a cooler hand.
  • Break-in: mesh gloves break-in faster than all leather gloves because mesh is not nearly as stiff as leather.

Mike Moustakas Rawlings Pro Mesh Glove

On the flip side, mesh is not as strong as leather. That means a mesh glove will not last as long as a full-leather glove. Keep that in mind before you jump to buy a mesh glove.

Yadier Molina’s Rawlings Heart of the Hide PROSCM41JB

Pros can get a new glove whenever they want, so the lighter weight is worth it. Adam Jones had used a mesh glove for a few years and Molina, the best catcher in the league, has continued to use mesh on his game gloves.

alcides-escobar-rawlings-glove

Alcides Escobar’s Rawlings Heart of the Hide PROPL217JB

 

Former LSU OFer Chris Sciambra’s Wilson A2000 Superskin 1799

Wilson

Wilson offers one synthetic material: Superskin. Pros like Hanley Ramirez, Dee Gordon, Mookie Betts, and Robinson Cano have Superskin on the back of their gloves. Wilson now offers Superskin in four colors: Red, Black, Blue, and White.

Hanley Ramirez Wilson A2000 1B Mitt Superskin

Hanley Ramirez Wilson A2000 1B Mitt Superskin

The benefits of Superskin include:

  • lighter weight. Wilson claims Superskin 1/2 the weight of leather.
  • stronger: Superskin is very strong and durable.
  • water-resistant: Superskin sheds water, great for using your gloves during rainy games.
dee-gordon-wilson-a2000-1786-gloves

Dee Gordon Wilson A2000 1786 Gloves

I believe Wilson when they say Superskin is “half the weight of leather but twice as strong.” Superskin is actually indestructible but somehow still light weight. Dee Gordon is still using his Superskin glove as is Robinson Cano. Hanley has trusted the Red Superskin for two seasons now.

Robinson Cano Wilson A2000 1786 Glove

Robinson Cano Wilson A2000 1786 Glove

 

You can shop Wilson Superskin gloves here.

Nike

Nike was pushing a technology called “Hyperfuse” last year on their Vapor 360 gloves, a synthetic material that is lighter than leather. Though pros like Matt Kemp, George Springer, and Carlos Gonzalez have used the Hyperfuse technology in games, the word in the clubhouse is that these didn’t hold up very well.

@geminikeez

@geminikeez

Hyperfuse is used on the thumb, pinky, and wrist to give a lighter feel. The Hyperfuse is also more breathable than leather due to the porous structure. Hyperfuse is not known to be all that strong, however, but Carlos Gonzalez has been using the Hyperfuse technology for a few years now.

carlos-gonzalez-nike-glove

Carlos Gonzalez’ Nike Vapor 360

We interviewed a UNC player who used a Hyperfuse glove a while back, and the answers that he gave us didn’t give the impressions that the Hyperfuse gloves are that good. Here are some of the comments about the gloves:

  • About the durability: “Very stiff at the beginning, but got pretty floppy towards the end.  A little too light and the “leather” didn’t really hold up from what I saw” and “once it was broken in the shape didn’t hold very long.”
  • About how his teammates liked them: “At the beginning I think guys liked the look but they didn’t seem too thrilled with them after that.”
  • Would you recommend?: “Nah I wouldn’t.”

You can read the full article here.

George Springer’s Nike Vapor 360

Meanwhile, you can shop the MVP Select Hyperfuse gloves (Like Kemp and the UNC team used) here and the Vapor 360 Hyperfuse gloves (Like Car-Go and Springer use) here.

Final Thoughts

My favorite of the synthetic materials has to be Superskin. The fact that it is lightweight but still stronger than leather is unmatched by the Hyperfuse and Rawlings mesh.  I would still go for the mesh if you want a lighter Rawlings glove. The Hyperfuse is not up to par to the other synthetics, but is the lightest of the batch. Synthetics are great buys and companies are investing a lot of money and time into developing them, so expect synthetics to get better and better over time.

Love it? Hate it? Notice an error? Hit us up!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *